IPEの果樹園2022
今週のReview
3/14-19
*****************************
プーチンのウクライナ侵攻 ・・・ウクライナ戦争とEU ・・・ハイブリッド戦争と核兵器 ・・・ウクライナ戦争と民主主義 ・・・プーチンとオリガルヒ ・・・ロシアと経済制裁 ・・・世界経済と制裁 ・・・ウクライナ戦争と難民危機 ・・・バイデンの内政・外交 ・・・ウクライナ戦争と中国 ・・・IMFとアルゼンチン ・・・市場価値の再評価 ・・・ウクライナ和平と秩序再建
［Review関連コラム集］
******************************
主要な出典 FP: Foreign Policy, FT: Financial Times, Foreign Policy, The Guardian, NYT: New York Times, PS: Project Syndicate, SPIEGEL International, VOX: VoxEU.orgそして、The Economist (London)
［これは英文コラムの紹介です．私の関心に従って，いくつか要点を紹介しています．Google翻訳を基に、修正しています。関心を持たれた方は正しい内容を必ず自分で確かめてください．著者と掲載機関の著作権に従います．］
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 人種について
NYT March 3, 2022
We Need a New Language for Talking About Race
By Henry Louis Gates Jr. and Andrew S. Curran
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● プーチンのウクライナ侵攻
NYT March 3, 2022
The Week That Awoke the World
By David Brooks
The Guardian, Fri 4 Mar 2022
This bloody invasion is turning the march of history into a sprint – and it’s not going Putin’s way
Jonathan Freedland
FT March 4, 2022
Putin proves my point. Whatever it is
Robert Shrimsley
FT March 4, 2022
Putin’s actions make no sense. That is his strength
Tim Harford
PS Mar 4, 2022
PS Commentators Explain the Ukraine War's Fallout
PS EDITORS
NYT March 4, 2022
‘I Want Peace.’ Zelensky’s Heroic Resistance Is an Example for the World.
By The Editorial Board
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Has Putin Lost the Plot?
By Amy Mackinnon, a national security and intelligence reporter at Foreign Policy.
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Putin’s War Has Middle Eastern Countries Hedging Their Bets
By David Schenker, a senior fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Humanitarian Corridors Alone Won’t Solve the Conflict in Ukraine
By Tjada D’Oyen McKenna, the chief executive officer of Mercy Corps.
FT March 5, 2022
Putin’s plan is failing in ways he could not have imagined
Simon Schama
FT March 5, 2022
The debt that pleasure owes to power
Janan Ganesh
The Guardian, Sun 6 Mar 2022
History replays like a half-forgotten song, but once we remember, it’s far too late
Neal Ascherson
The Guardian, Sun 6 Mar 2022
The more Ukraine resists, the greater the danger to Nato. It should act now to stop the slaughter
Simon Tisdall
NYT March 6, 2022
Boris Johnson: 6 Steps the West Must Take to Help Ukraine Right Now
By Boris Johnson
NYT March 6, 2022
The Cancellation of Mother Russia Is Underway
By Thomas L. Friedman
FP MARCH 6, 2022
Putin Has a Grimly Absolute Vision of the ‘Russian World’
By Benjamin R. Young, an assistant professor at the Wilder School of Government & Public Affairs.
FP MARCH 6, 2022
Russia’s Ukraine Invasion Devolving Into ‘Strategic Catastrophe’ for Putin: U.S. Envoy
By Robbie Gramer, a diplomacy and national security reporter at Foreign Policy.
FT March 7, 2022
Russia is once again behind an iron curtain
Gideon Rachman
PS Mar 7, 2022
Putin's Potemkin Military
DANIEL GROS
FP MARCH 7, 2022
There Is a West
By James Traub, a columnist at Foreign Policy and nonresident fellow at New York University’s Center on International Cooperation.
FP MARCH 7, 2022
Why the World Can’t Ditch Diplomacy in Putin’s War
By Mary Yang, an intern at Foreign Policy.
FT March 8, 2022
Vladimir Putin’s stealthy reabsorption of Belarus
NYT March 8, 2022
Putin Has No Good Way Out, and That Really Scares Me
By Thomas L. Friedman
FP MARCH 9, 2022
Ukraine Wants NATO Jets. Biden Says Not Yet.
By Amy Mackinnon, a national security and intelligence reporter at Foreign Policy, and Jack Detsch, Foreign Policy’s Pentagon and national security reporter.
NYT March 10, 2022
How Vladimir Putin Lost Interest in the Present
By Mikhail Zygar
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ戦争とEU
The Guardian, Fri 4 Mar 2022
In this moment of crisis, opening the door to Ukraine is one thing the EU can do
Timothy Garton Ash
FT March 6, 2022
Ukraine invasion nudges Germany towards new security mindset
Erika Solomon in Berlin
FT March 6, 2022
A new Europe is emerging from the tragedy of Ukraine
Sylvie Kauffmann
PS Mar 7, 2022
Explaining Europe's Reaction
DIEGO GAMBETTA, STEPHEN HOLMES
The Guardian, Wed 9 Mar 2022
History is brutally back, and Ukraine will test Europe’s appetite for the consequences
Luuk van Middelaar
FT March 9, 2022
War in Ukraine: will the Baltics become the ‘new West Berlin’?
Richard Milne in Riga
FP FEBRUARY 9, 2022
To Deter Russia, Europe Needs More Military Integration
By Elisabeth Braw, a columnist at Foreign Policy and a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ハイブリッド戦争と核兵器
FT March 4, 2022
Russia’s nuclear alert means Nato must tread carefully
Jeremy Shapiro
NYT March 4, 2022
I’ve Dealt With Foreign Cyberattacks. America Isn’t Ready for What’s Coming.
By Glenn S. Gerstell
FT March 5, 2022
The west’s hybrid war on Russia
Robin Wigglesworth, Colby Smith and Claire Jones
NYT March 5, 2022
How to Stop a Nuclear War
By Ross Douthat
FT March 7, 2022
Ukraine reveals nature of war in the age of weaponised networks
Rana Foroohar
PS Mar 7, 2022
The Nuclear Threat Is Back
MOHAMED ELBARADEI
FP MARCH 7, 2022
In Putin’s War, the Map Is Not the Territory
By Mateusz Fafinski, a historian of late antiquity and the Middle Ages.
FP FEBRUARY 8, 2022
Russia’s Propaganda Machine Is Faltering Over Ukraine
By Ian Garner, a historian and translator of Russian war propaganda.
FP FEBRUARY 8, 2022
Virality Isn’t Victory for Ukraine
By Elisabeth Braw, a columnist at Foreign Policy and a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.
FT March 10, 2022
Doom-scrollers, beware the feel-good social media posts in times of war
Hannah Murphy
FT March 10, 2022
What Google knows about the future of war
Gillian Tett
FT March 10, 2022
Russia’s digital iron curtain will fail
John Thornhill
PS Mar 10, 2022
How to Disrupt the Fake News Market
MOHAMED SULIMAN
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ戦争と民主主義
FT March 4, 2022
Ukraine has shaken the world’s older democracies out of our malaise
Chrystia Freeland
PS Mar 4, 2022
The Global Struggle for Democracy Is in Ukraine
SUSAN STOKES
The Guardian, Sat 5 Mar 2022
Far right and far left alike admired Putin. Now we’ve all turned against strongmen
Nick Cohen
NYT March 7, 2022
How to Keep the Rising Tide of Fake News From Drowning Our Democracy
By Richard L. Hasen
FT March 8, 2022
Why the Ukraine crisis is so bad for western populists
Janan Ganesh
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● プーチンとオリガルヒ
FP MARCH 4, 2022
How to Stop Oil Companies From Propping Up Kleptocrats
By Alexandra Gillies, an advisor at the Natural Resource Governance Institute
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Ukraine Implores Biden to Sanction Putin’s ‘Sacred Cow’
By Amy Mackinnon, a national security and intelligence reporter at Foreign Policy, and Robbie Gramer, a diplomacy and national security reporter at Foreign Policy.
FT March 5, 2022
England’s law, not its lawyers, is to blame for the oligarch gold rush
David Allen Green
FP MARCH 5, 2022
‘Life Is Becoming Impossible’: Activists Say Sanctions on Russian Oligarchs Don’t Go Far Enough
By Jack Detsch, Foreign Policy’s Pentagon and national security reporter.
FT March 8, 2022
The City of London’s Russia ties need to be cut
Helen Thomas
The Guardian, Thu 10 Mar 2022
Why are oligarchs so necessary in Britain? Because we love living beyond our means
Larry Elliott
The Guardian, Thu 10 Mar 2022
How the British upper class came to serve the global elite
Andy Beckett
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ロシアと経済制裁
PS Mar 4, 2022
Boycott Russian Energy Now
OLEG USTENKO
NYT March 4, 2022
Wonking Out: Putin’s Other Big Miscalculation
By Paul Krugman
FT March 5, 2022
Football faces a moment of reckoning
Henry Mance
FT March 5, 2022
Elvira Nabiullina, a technocrat plunged into chaos at Russia’s central bank
FT reporters in London
FT March 7, 2022
The chilling effect of sanctions on Russia
Jonathan Guthrie
The Guardian, Tue 8 Mar 2022
The sanctions strategy is flawed. To defeat Putin, you have to know how the Kremlin works
Olga Chyzh
The Guardian, Tue 8 Mar 2022
All-out economic warfare is the best way to stop Putin
Orysia Lutsevych
FT March 8, 2022
Big Tech faces a moral reckoning in Ukraine
Marietje Schaake
FP FEBRUARY 8, 2022
U.S.-Venezuelan Oil Deal Should Not Forget Democracy
By David Smilde, a professor of human relations at Tulane University.
The Guardian, Wed 9 Mar 2022
It’s not too late to free ourselves from this idiotic addiction to Russian gas
George Monbiot
FT March 9, 2022
Sanctions more than ethics have spurred corporate flight from Russia
Alan Beattie
FT March 9, 2022
Pari Passu Saga 2.0?
Robin Wigglesworth
PS Mar 9, 2022
Fortress Russia Crumbles
ANDERS ÅSLUND
NYT March 9, 2022
C.E.O.s Are Going Out of Their Way to Punish Russia
By Peter Coy
FT March 10, 2022
The corporate retreat from Russia is going to be messy
Cat Rutter Pooley
FP MARCH 10, 2022
How Europe Can Slash Fossil Fuels and Frustrate Putin
By Lauri Myllyvirta, the lead analyst at the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air.
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 世界経済と制裁
FT March 4, 2022
Emerging markets: where investing and politics meet
Stefan Wagstyl
FT March 4, 2022
The bleak market outcome for Russia after Ukraine invasion
Paul McNamara
FT March 5, 2022
War in Ukraine sparks a commodity crisis
FT March 7, 2022
Russia’s war on Ukraine threatens a global food security crisis
Oleg Ustenko
FT March 7, 2022
Why oil prices might still climb higher
Derek Brower
PS Mar 7, 2022
The Ukraine War's Multifaceted Economic Fallout
MOHAMED A. EL-ERIAN
PS Mar 8, 2022
Markets Are in Denial About Nuclear Risk
WILLEM H. BUITER
PS Mar 8, 2022
Closing Tax Havens Is the True Test of the West's Resolve
DARON ACEMOGLU
PS Mar 8, 2022
Putin's War and World Energy
NICK BUTLER
NYT March 8, 2022
How the Putin Shock Might Affect the World Economy
By Paul Krugman
FT March 9, 2022
There are no good choices for the west on Ukraine
Martin Wolf
VOX 09 March 2022
Cutting Russia’s fossil fuel exports: Short-term pain for long-term gain
Maksym Chepeliev, Thomas Hertel, Dominique van der Mensbrugghe
VOX 10 March 2022
Economic consequences of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine: Views of leading economists
Romesh Vaitilingam
VOX 10 March 2022
Sanctions, war, and systemic risk in 1914 and 2022
Jon Danielsson, Charles Goodhart, Robert Macrae
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 気候変動
PS Mar 4, 2022
Greening African Cooking
BRIAN MALIKA
FT March 5, 2022
A future based on hydrogen fuel seems a way off
John Dizard
The Observer, Sun 6 Mar 2022
The Observer view on Ukraine and the climate emergency
Observer editorial
FT March 8, 2022
Will the Ukraine war derail the green energy transition?
Leslie Hook and Neil Hume
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ戦争と難民危機
FP MARCH 4, 2022
There Could Be 10 Million Ukrainians Fleeing Putin’s Bombs
By Bart M. J. Szewczyk, a nonresident senior fellow at the German Marshall Fund and an adjunct professor at Sciences Po.
The Observer, Sun 6 Mar 2022
The Observer view on Ukraine and western support
Observer editorial
FT March 6, 2022
Britain must not ignore its obligations to vulnerable refugees
Dominic Grieve
The Guardian, Mon 7 Mar 2022
Syria, Afghanistan, Ukraine: how many refugee crises can the world cope with?
Anushka Asthana
FP MARCH 7, 2022
In Ukraine, Refugees Flee West—and Volunteer Fighters Flood to the East
By Stefanie Glinski, a journalist and photographer who reports on conflict and humanitarian crisis.
The Guardian, Tue 8 Mar 2022
A world-leading visa system? Tell that to Ukrainian refugees who can’t get past Calais
Marina Hyde
NYT March 8, 2022
We Should Welcome Ukrainian Refugees. And Russians, Too.
By Ilya Somin
FT March 9, 2022
The UK’s shameful Ukrainian refugee policy
PS Mar 9, 2022
How Europe Can Include Ukrainian Refugees in Society
HRISHABH SANDILYA, ZHIVKA DELEVA
The Guardian, Thu 10 Mar 2022
Europe has rediscovered compassion for refugees – but only if they’re white
Daniel Howden
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● バイデンの内政・外交
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Biden Eyes Adding Top Foreign-Policy Strategist
By Jack Detsch, Foreign Policy’s Pentagon and national security reporter, and Robbie Gramer, a diplomacy and national security reporter at Foreign Policy.
NYT March 6, 2022
Biden’s Pro-Labor Vision Goes Beyond America
By Farah Stockman
The Guardian, Tue 8 Mar 2022
Donald Trump’s power is fading: Trumpism is the clear and present danger now
Rebecca Solnit
NYT March 8, 2022
The War in Ukraine Puts America’s Problems in Perspective
By John McWhorter
NYT March 9, 2022
There Are Glimmers of Hope for Biden. Or Maybe Slivers.
By Thomas B. Edsall
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ戦争と中国
FP MARCH 4, 2022
Putin’s War Is Xi’s Worst Nightmare
By Craig Singleton, a senior China fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies and a former U.S. diplomat.
PS Mar 7, 2022
Only China Can Stop Russia
STEPHEN S. ROACH
PS Mar 7, 2022
China's Moment of Decision
YASHENG HUANG
NYT March 7, 2022
Why China Can’t Bail Out Putin’s Economy
By Paul Krugman
The Guardian, Tue 8 Mar 2022
The Guardian view on China and Russia: enough in common
Editorial
FT March 9, 2022
Beijing takes ‘war lessons’ from Russia’s military tactics in Ukraine
Kathrin Hille in Taipei
PS Mar 9, 2022
Can Sanctions on Russia Work Without China?
SHANG-JIN WEI
FT March 10, 2022
The rising costs of China’s friendship with Russia
Tom Mitchell in Singapore, Demetri Sevastopulo in Washington, Sun Yu in Beijing and James Kynge in London
PS Mar 10, 2022
How China Can End the War in Ukraine
STEPHEN S. ROACH
PS Mar 10, 2022
Will Putin's War Slow China's Growth?
NANCY QIAN
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 日本企業の革新
FT March 6, 2022
Sony and Honda’s EV venture is a lesson for corporate Japan
Leo Lewis
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● UK政治
FT March 6, 2022
Rishi Sunak owes Britain more than warmed-over Thatcherism
Martin Wolf
FT March 9, 2022
Ukraine has saved Boris Johnson for now, but dangers remain
Robert Shrimsley
FT March 9, 2022
UK’s sanctions struggle may have broader lessons
Helen Thomas
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ローマ帝国
FP MARCH 6, 2022
A Shiny (and Wrong) Vision of Roman Imperialism
By Bret Devereaux, a historian specializing in the Roman economy and military.
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● IMFとアルゼンチン
PS Mar 7, 2022
The IMF's Unfinished Business
JOSEPH E. STIGLITZ, KEVIN P. GALLAGHER
PS Mar 10, 2022
The IMF's Agreement with Argentina Could Be a Game Changer
JOSEPH E. STIGLITZ, MARK WEISBROT
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 韓国大統領選挙
FP FEBRUARY 7, 2022
South Korea Wants to Be a Player, Not a Bystander
By Kuyoun Chung, an assistant professor of political science at Kangwon National University in South Korea, and Andrew Yeo, SK-Korea Foundation chair and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and professor of politics at the Catholic University of America in Washington, D.C.
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● コロナウイルス
FT March 8, 2022
Hong Kong is stuck in limbo as Covid cases soar
Ravi Mattu
FT March 10, 2022
When do we declare the Covid pandemic over?
Anjana Ahuja
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ戦争とインド
PS Mar 8, 2022
India's Ukraine Tightrope
SHASHI THAROOR
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● 女性の価値の再評価
PS Mar 8, 2022
What If Our Economy Valued What Matters?
MARIANA MAZZUCATO
PS Mar 8, 2022
Empowering African Women to Shape the Continent's Future
RUTH OKOWA, MUNSHI SULAIMAN
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● ウクライナ和平と秩序再建
FP FEBRUARY 7, 2022
Why Naftali Bennett Went to Moscow
By Neri Zilber, a journalist covering Middle East politics.
NYT March 8, 2022
New Rules for a New World
By Bret Stephens
FP FEBRUARY 8, 2022
Hints of a Ukraine-Russia Deal?
By Michael Hirsh, a senior correspondent at Foreign Policy
FP FEBRUARY 8, 2022
An International Relations Theory Guide to the War in Ukraine
By Stephen M. Walt, a columnist at Foreign Policy and the Robert and Renée Belfer professor of international relations at Harvard University.
FT March 9, 2022
Russia is close to sabotaging the Iran nuclear deal
David Gardner
PS Mar 9, 2022
Diplomacy Remains the Only Option in Ukraine
JEFFREY D. SACHS
PS Mar 9, 2022
Taming the Security Dilemma
DANI RODRIK
NYT March 9, 2022
They Predicted the Ukraine War. But Did They Still Get It Wrong?
By Ross Douthat
FP MARCH 9, 2022
In Backing Russia on Ukraine, Iran Is on the Wrong Side of History
By Kourosh Ziabari, a journalist and Asia Times correspondent
FP MARCH 9, 2022
Ukraine Is Europe’s Chance for Renewal
By Timothy Snyder, a professor of history at Yale University.
FP MARCH 9, 2022
Europe’s New Security Unity Can Repair Damaged Relationships
By Azeem Ibrahim, a columnist at Foreign Policy and a director at the Newlines Institute for Strategy and Policy.
FP MARCH 9, 2022
Russia’s ‘Eleventh-Hour’ Interference in the Iran Deal
By Colum Lynch, a senior staff writer at Foreign Policy.
The Guardian, Thu 10 Mar 2022
Rupture is not an option: after this war, the west must learn how to live with Russia
Martin Kettle
FT March 10, 2022
Dmytro Kuleba: the EU must grant Ukraine membership now
Dmytro Kuleba
FT March 10, 2022
Russia, Ukraine and the spectre of 1941
Simon Kuper
PS Mar 10, 2022
The Monetary Consequences of Vladimir Putin
BARRY EICHENGREEN
FP MARCH 10, 2022
Turkey’s Balancing Act on Ukraine Is Becoming More Precarious
By Jeffrey Mankoff, a distinguished research fellow at the U.S. National Defense University’s Institute for National Strategic Studies
FP MARCH 10, 2022
Putin’s War Could Save the Global Economic Order
By Edward Alden, a columnist at Foreign Policy, a visiting professor at Western Washington University, and a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations
FT March 11, 2022
What neutrality would mean for Ukraine, Russia and the war
Daniel Dombey in Madrid, Ben Hall in London and Ayla Jean Yackley in Istanbul
FT March 11, 2022
War in Ukraine could accelerate the growth of the crypto sector
Gillian Tett
FT March 11, 2022
Toppling the dollar as reserve currency risks harmful fragmentation
Robin Harding
―――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――――
● チリ
FT March 10, 2022
Chile can set an example again for the developing world
********************************
The Economist February 19th 2022
The Ukraine crisis: A grim look out
China and Africa: Chasing the dragon
The Conservative Party: Old dudes
Free exchange: The wonks’ weapons
（コメント） プーチンの脅迫による成果は、その制裁に比べて値しないだろう。やめた方がよい、という記事が、今では読むに値しないか? もう1つの記事は、プーチンが支持基盤とした富裕層、都市中産階級、批判的な若者たちにも注目します。
むしろ、より印象的な記事は、中国の投資や融資とハイスピードの建築作業がアフリカを世界にリンクしたことを伝えます。そして、イギリス保守党の分裂症と、それがもたらした指導者、ボリス・ジョンソンのガバナンス崩壊。
経済制裁は機能しない、という研究の紹介を、今こそ深刻に読みます。
******************************
IPEの想像力 3/14/29
暖かくなった日曜日、新薬師寺の十二神将像を初めて観ました。1300年を経た国宝です。キエフにある同じような歴史遺産が、今、破壊されていると思うと、息が詰まります。
ウクライナ国境で家族が引き裂かれている、という記事を読みました。女性や子供を国外に避難させて、男たちはロシア軍の侵攻を止めるために戦おうとしています。
戦争は終わらず、犠牲者が増え続ける圧力の下で外交をつくします。小国の側に最新鋭兵器や財源を支援することは、ロシアの勝利を困難にするでしょう。しかし、戦争を止めるわけではありません。双方の犠牲者が急激に増えています。
降伏することは、ロシア軍の占領と治安部隊による粛清、政治体制の強制転換を意味する、という恐怖があります。ウクライナ軍は、たとえ犠牲者が増え続けると分かっていても、ロシア軍の侵攻に抵抗し、形勢を逆転するか、少なくとも均衡化をめざします。
プーチンは核戦争を警告し、NATOの参戦を阻みます。経済制裁の効果は、ロシア経済を隔離し、破滅させるとともに、世界市場の分割を促すと予想されます。
政府は、戦争の戦い方・戦術を選択する必要がある、と思います。ウクライナ側の犠牲者をできるだけ減らし、ロシア軍による侵攻と占領の財政・経済的コストを増やすことです。ウクライナ軍は都市部の防衛をあきらめて、都市の外に分散して多くの拠点を築くでしょう。都市に残される住民たちが人道支援を受け、ロシア側の情報操作や政治工作に抵抗することへの国際監視・支援を強化することも含めて、長期の抵抗を組織します。
戦争が膠着状態になることで、終結に向けて、双方の戦略目標と、地域や世界の主要国が支持する新しい戦後秩序に関心が集中します。
戦争目的は何か? 戦後秩序をどうするのか? 戦争は、交渉によって停止します。地震や津波ではないのです。
****
3・11は東日本大震災と福島原発事故の記念日です。ウクライナ戦争の報道と重なって、私は難民の帰還や財政負担のことを考えました。
放射能汚染の影響は続き、帰還を希望する住民は減っています。原発の再稼働や、土地の嵩上げ、住宅の移転、堤防を築くことで次の津波のコストを減らす、という目標の設定は、最初から間違っていた、と私は思います。
日本政府は、離散家族の雇用と住宅より、巨大な堤防で海を遮断することに、財源を消尽し、国民に負担を強いました。地域産業・コミュニティの再建と、住民による避難支援システムを整備するべきだった、と私は思います。
****
今から思えば、プーチンの主張した、ロシアの安全保障上の懸念を、欧米諸国は真剣に扱うべきでした。NATOを拡大するより、ロシアを（そしてプーチンを）包摂する安全保障の枠組みを優先していたら、ウクライナ戦争は回避できたかもしれない、と思います。
大国と国際機関は役割を果たすべきです。大国は中立地帯や非核化・非武装地帯を設け、これらを拡大すること。非核諸国の圧力で、次の戦争を回避する交渉と、核兵器を保有する軍事大国への経済制裁発動を明確にすること。
大規模な避難を支援し、早期の帰還をめざすために、交戦地帯から逃れる難民に、国際的に保障された居住区域を設け、衣食住と医療・教育、働く機会を提供します。
女性や子供たちが家族と再会できる日に、殺戮と外交交渉、経済制裁、国際支援、戦争に関わる意思決定と結果の検証が、国際社会の責任で進む光景を観るでしょう。
戦争とは何か? 戦争を冒す者に厳しく問う十二神将がよみがえります。
******************************